Is 1% FDR Really 1%? I Hid 14,567 Arabidopsis Proteins in MaxQuant, FragPipe and DIA-NN Searches
I added an Arabidopsis proteome that cannot be in the sample to the search database of the same human, yeast and E. coli runs, and counted how often MaxQuant 2.8.1, FragPipe 24 and DIA-NN 2.3.2 reported it at 1% FDR. Precursors and peptides stayed well inside 1%. Protein groups did not always: the estimate was 2.09% for FragPipe, 1.33% for MaxQuant and 1.37% for DIA-NN without MBR. Match-between-runs transfers added little error.